KeyNaturals organic medicinal mushroom extracts

What exactly is a mushroom extract, and why does it matter what it contains?

In 2015, the New York State Attorney General sent cease-and-desist letters to some of the world's largest retail chains – Walmart, Walgreens, Target, and GNC – requiring them to remove their private-label plant supplements from sale. The reason: DNA testing showed that only 21% of the products contained what was stated on the label. In Walmart's case, this percentage dropped to 4%.

It was not a problem of insufficient concentration. The ingredient was simply not present.

This case highlights something every consumer should consider before buying a dietary supplement: In an industry with lax regulations and highly competitive pricing, what is stated on the packaging does not always match the actual contents. That is why it is worth understanding what is really in the product you buy.


Whole Mushroom vs. Extract: They Are Not the Same

When we talk about a whole mushroom in powder form, that is exactly what we mean: the mushroom that has been ground up and filled into capsules. It is also the most cost-effective manufacturing option, which is reflected in the final price. Many uninformed consumers make their decision based on this information. The problem is not the dosage form itself – mushroom powder has its place and its tradition –, but the lack of knowledge about what you are actually buying. Anyone who buys powder while believing they are purchasing an extract is making a decision without the most important information.

An extract concentrates the bioactive compounds through a process – using hot water, alcohol, or both – that breaks down the cell wall and releases them in a form that is more readily available to the body. The result is a product with a higher density of bioactive compounds and generally higher bioavailability. These are different formats with different profiles, and they should be clearly distinguished on the label so that the consumer can make an informed choice.


Bioactive Compounds: What Exactly Are We Talking About?

Every mushroom has its own chemical fingerprint. The best-studied ingredients determine the profile of each species:

  • Reishi is known for its triterpenes and beta-glucans.
  • Lion's mane mushroom is characterized by hericenones and erinacines.
  • Chaga mushroom contains betulin and a high concentration of phenolic compounds.
  • Cordyceps contains cordycepin and adenosine.

For these compounds to be present in a product in a meaningful amount, they must first be present in the raw material and then correctly extracted. If either of these two steps fails, the bottle may contain very little – or nothing at all – of what the label promises.


Mycelium Is Not the Mushroom

This needs clarification, as it often leads to confusion.

The fruiting body is the part of the mushroom that we can see: the cap and the stem. This is where the bioactive compounds are naturally concentrated.

Mycelium is the network of threads that grows underground or in a substrate – the "root" part of the mushroom. Many products on the market use mycelium grown in grain, as this is cheaper and faster to produce.

The problem has two aspects. The first is legal: a product made from mycelium generally cannot be marketed in the EU. The second is more subtle and difficult to detect on the label: Some of these products show seemingly reasonable beta-glucan levels, but these beta-glucans do not come from the mushroom. They come from the grain on which the mycelium was grown. These are beta-glucans from oats or rice, not the typical beta-glucans found in reishi, chaga, or lion's mane. The label does not lie about the numbers, but the context completely changes their meaning.

How to Find Out What You Are Buying

A good extract should be able to answer the following questions:

  • Does it come from the fruiting body or from mycelium?
  • What type of extraction was used?
  • What concentration of bioactive compounds does it contain, and where do they come from?

If this information is not available, it is difficult to know what you are actually buying. And in a market where products are increasing faster than transparency, these questions are the best compass.

The dry extracts from KeyNaturals contain a QR code that links directly to the clinical analysis of the batch: which ingredients are included, in what concentration, and how they were obtained. Not as a sales pitch, but because anyone who decides to take a product has the right to know exactly what they are taking.


Do you have questions about any of the mushrooms in our range? Write to us or register in the professional area at keynaturals.net.